Five Star Bank: Current Interest Rates, Checking & Savings Accounts, Ratings & Complaints

Home > Lender Reviews > Five Star Bank

Editor's Rating

RateZip's Editors follow standards of editorial integrity. Our goal is to help you make informed financial decisions. Some products that we review may be offered by companies who also buy advertising from us.

Here is our advertising disclosure.


Five Star Bank has a legacy that extends back to the 1850's. Wolcott Humphrey is the great grandfather of the current President and CEO, Peter Humphrey founded a community bank in Warsaw, New York, called the Wyoming County Bank. Mr. Humphrey's vision was to focus on local communities and their people, and the bank has never lost this focus.

The company has gone through many changes over the years, and is now known as Five Star Bank. Five Star Bank is the result of combining the Wyoming County Bank with Bath National Bank, First Tier Bank & Trust, National Bank of Geneva, and Pavilion State Bank. It however is still being led by the Humphrey Family.

The bank has over 2.6 Billion USD in assets, conducts business in 14 counties in Western and Central New York, and employs around 600 people. The bank has nearly 50 branches and around 70 ATMs. At Five Star Bank you can find mortgage loans, high yield savings accounts, home equity loans, CDs and many other competitive banking products.

Fulfilling Wolcott Humphrey's vision, Five Star Bank remains heavily involved in the communities that it serves. Five Star supports the United Way, started a volunteer group known as the S.T.A.R. Volunteer Program, and supports many programs geared toward helping young people. It seems safe to say that Mr. Humphrey would be proud of his bank if he could see it today.

Want to see how Five Star Bank interest rates fare against other lenders? Find out now!

This bank profile is not an endorsement or advertisement for the bank's products and services.  RateZip is an independent publisher of bank information.

Compare banks for mortgage, auto, savings and CD rates. Browse bank rates. Search locally or nationally for the best finance rates.
Search locally or nationally
Compare banks for mortgage, auto, savings and CD rates.